| # | Player | Team | Rnd | Pick | From | Pos | Country | League |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | Jeff Skinner |
 TOR
|
1 | 10 | STL | C |
CAN
|
OHL |
| 23 | Beau Bennett |
TOR
|
1 | 23 | VAN | W |
USA
|
BCHL |
| 43 | Dalton Smith |
TOR
|
2 | 13 | PHX | W |
CAN
|
OHL |
| 71 | Philip Lane |
TOR
|
3 | 11 | DET | W |
USA
|
OHL |
| 72 | Mark Alt |
TOR
|
3 | 12 | D |
USA
|
HIGH-MN | |
| 78 | Kent Simpson |
TOR
|
3 | 18 | EDM | G |
CAN
|
WHL |
| 86 | Danny Biega |
TOR
|
3 | 26 | BUF | D |
CAN
|
ECAC |
| 160 | Jason Wilson |
TOR
|
6 | 10 | STL | W |
CAN
|
OHL |
| 162 | John Klingberg |
TOR
|
6 | 12 | D |
SWE
|
SWEDEN-JR. | |
| 180 | Brendan O'Donnell |
TOR
|
6 | 30 | PHL | C |
CAN
|
MJHL |
| 200 | Dylen McKinlay |
TOR
|
7 | 20 | ANH | W |
CAN
|
WHL |