| # | Player | Team | Rnd | Pick | From | Pos | Country | League | Yrs | GP | G | A | P |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 | Peter Holland |
 BUF
|
1 | 26 | C |
CAN
|
OHL | 4 | 253 | 22 | 24 | 46 | |
| 38 | Jeremy Morin |
BUF
|
2 | 8 | MIN | W |
USA
|
USDP | 3 | 15 | 1 | 3 | 4 |
| 52 | Joonas Nattinen |
BUF
|
2 | 22 | CHI | C |
FIN
|
Finland Jr. | |||||
| 70 | Eric Gelinas |
BUF
|
3 | 10 | FLA | D |
CAN
|
QMJHL | 3 | 42 | 0 | 3 | 3 |
| 83 | Cody Eakin |
BUF
|
3 | 23 | COL | C |
CAN
|
WHL | 9 | 698 | 91 | 143 | 234 |
| 84 | Mac Bennett |
BUF
|
3 | 24 | NYI | D |
USA
|
HIGH-CT | |||||
| 86 | Sami Vatanen |
BUF
|
3 | 26 | D |
FIN
|
Finland Jr. | 8 | 562 | 63 | 274 | 337 | |
| 88 | Ryan Bourque |
BUF
|
3 | 28 | SJS | C |
USA
|
USDP | |||||
| 89 | Jerry D'amigo |
BUF
|
3 | 29 | OTT | W |
USA
|
USDP | 1 | 16 | 1 | 1 | 2 |
| 95 | Seth Helgeson |
BUF
|
4 | 5 | BOS | D |
USA
|
USHL | 2 | 4 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 109 | Jimmy Bubnick |
BUF
|
4 | 19 | NJD | C |
CAN
|
WHL | |||||
| 130 | Byron Froese |
BUF
|
5 | 10 | FLA | C |
CAN
|
WHL | 5 | 303 | 28 | 32 | 60 |
| 137 | Levko Koper |
BUF
|
5 | 17 | EDM | W |
CAN
|
WHL | |||||
| 146 | Tommi Kivisto |
BUF
|
5 | 26 | D |
FIN
|
WHL | ||||||
| 156 | Jaroslav Janus |
BUF
|
6 | 6 | VAN | G |
SVK
|
OHL | |||||
| 158 | Rasmus Rissanen |
BUF
|
6 | 8 | MIN | D |
FIN
|
Finland Jr. | |||||
| 159 | Jere Sallinen |
BUF
|
6 | 9 | WSH | F |
FIN
|
Finland Jr. | |||||
| 163 | Garrett Mitchell |
BUF
|
6 | 13 | NYR | W |
CAN
|
WHL | |||||
| 164 | Tyler Randell |
BUF
|
6 | 14 | PHL | W |
CAN
|
OHL | |||||
| 166 | Dave Labrecque |
BUF
|
6 | 16 | CGY | C |
CAN
|
QMJHL | |||||
| 170 | Petteri Simila |
BUF
|
6 | 20 | ANH | G |
FIN
|
Finland Jr. | |||||
| 172 | Dustin Walsh |
BUF
|
6 | 22 | CHI | C |
CAN
|
OJHL | |||||
| 176 | Mihail Pashnin |
BUF
|
6 | 26 | D |
RUS
|
RUSSIA-2 | ||||||
| 179 | Anders Lee |
BUF
|
6 | 29 | OTT | C |
USA
|
HIGH-MN | 11 | 881 | 202 | 225 | 427 |
| 182 | Jordan Nolan |
BUF
|
7 | 2 | TOR | C |
CAN
|
OHL | 6 | 301 | 22 | 23 | 45 |
| 188 | Michael Cichy |
BUF
|
7 | 8 | MIN | C |
USA
|
USHL | |||||
| 191 | Brett Flemming |
BUF
|
7 | 11 | NSH | D |
CAN
|
OHL | |||||
| 193 | Kirill Gotovets |
BUF
|
7 | 13 | NYR | D |
BLR
|
HIGH-MN | |||||
| 194 | Gus Young |
BUF
|
7 | 14 | PHL | D |
USA
|
HIGH-MA | |||||
| 198 | Jordan Samuels-Thomas |
BUF
|
7 | 18 | CAR | W |
USA
|
USHL | |||||
| 201 | Barron Smith |
BUF
|
7 | 21 | MTL | D |
USA
|
OHL | |||||
| 203 | Ben Sexton |
BUF
|
7 | 23 | COL | C |
CAN
|
CJHL | |||||
| 204 | Marek Viedensky |
BUF
|
7 | 24 | NYI | C |
SVK
|
WHL | |||||
| 205 | Michael Sdao |
BUF
|
7 | 25 | ATL | D |
USA
|
USHL | |||||
| 209 | Cameron Reid |
BUF
|
7 | 29 | OTT | C |
CAN
|
BCHL | |||||
| 210 | Dominik Bielke |
BUF
|
7 | 30 | STL | D |
DEU
|
GERMANY |