| # | Player | Team | Rnd | Pick | From | Pos | Country | League |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 13 | Tyler Myers |
 BUF
|
1 | 13 | D |
USA
|
WHL | |
| 22 | Luca Sbisa |
BUF
|
1 | 22 | D |
ITA
|
WHL | |
| 36 | Jacob Markstrom |
BUF
|
2 | 6 | G |
SWE
|
SWEDEN-JR. | |
| 53 | Kirill Petrov |
BUF
|
2 | 23 | W |
RUS
|
RUSSIA | |
| 60 | Roman Josi |
BUF
|
2 | 30 | D |
CHE
|
SWISS | |
| 61 | Cody Goloubef |
BUF
|
3 | 1 | D |
CAN
|
WCHA | |
| 62 | Brandon Burlon |
BUF
|
3 | 2 | D |
CAN
|
OPJHL | |
| 63 | David Toews |
BUF
|
3 | 3 | C |
CAN
|
HIGH-MN | |
| 67 | Jordon Southorn |
BUF
|
3 | 7 | D |
CAN
|
QMJHL | |
| 77 | Geordie Wudrick |
BUF
|
3 | 17 | W |
CAN
|
WHL | |
| 84 | Eric Mestery |
BUF
|
3 | 24 | D |
CAN
|
WHL | |
| 113 | Jamie Arniel |
BUF
|
4 | 23 | C |
CAN
|
OHL | |
| 117 | Corey Fienhage |
BUF
|
4 | 27 | D |
USA
|
HIGH-MN | |
| 121 | Mark Barberio |
BUF
|
5 | 1 | D |
CAN
|
QMJHL | |
| 134 | Justin Azevedo |
BUF
|
5 | 14 | C |
CAN
|
OHL | |
| 164 | Joel Broda |
BUF
|
6 | 14 | C |
CAN
|
WHL | |
| 165 | Teemu Hartikainen |
BUF
|
6 | 15 | C |
FIN
|
Finland Jr. | |
| 180 | Mitch Gaulton |
BUF
|
6 | 30 | D |
CAN
|
OHL | |
| 181 | Jean-Sebastien Berube |
BUF
|
7 | 1 | W |
CAN
|
QMJHL | |
| 194 | Joacim Eriksson |
BUF
|
7 | 14 | G |
SWE
|
SWEDEN-JR. | |
| 199 | Anders Lindback |
BUF
|
7 | 19 | G |
SWE
|
SWEDEN | |
| 201 | Samuel Morneau |
BUF
|
7 | 21 | W |
CAN
|
QMJHL | |
| 209 | Mark Goggin |
BUF
|
7 | 29 | C |
USA
|
HIGH-CT |