| # | Player | Team | Rnd | Pick | From | Pos | Country | League |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24 | James O'Brien |
 BUF
|
1 | 24 | EDM | C |
USA
|
WCHA |
| 88 | Justin Vaive |
BUF
|
3 | 28 | FLA | W |
USA
|
USDP |
| 103 | Luca Cunti |
BUF
|
4 | 13 | ATL | F |
CHE
|
SWISS-3 |
| 121 | Joseph Lavin |
BUF
|
5 | 1 | MIN | D |
USA
|
USDP |
| 124 | Corey Tropp |
BUF
|
5 | 4 | LAK | W |
USA
|
USHL |
| 131 | Niklas Lucenius |
BUF
|
5 | 11 | DAL | C |
FIN
|
FINLAND |
| 139 | Nick Larson |
BUF
|
5 | 19 | OTT | C |
USA
|
USHL |
| 140 | Jens Hellgren |
BUF
|
5 | 20 | NYI | D |
SWE
|
SWEDEN-JR. |
| 143 | Radim Ostrcil |
BUF
|
5 | 23 | NSH | D |
CZE
|
Czech Republic |
| 146 | Josh Unice |
BUF
|
5 | 26 | NJD | G |
USA
|
USDP |
| 147 | Corbin McPherson |
BUF
|
5 | 27 | BOS | D |
USA
|
BCHL |
| 152 | David Skokan |
BUF
|
6 | 2 | CLB | C |
SVK
|
QMJHL |
| 155 | Dustin Jeffrey |
BUF
|
6 | 5 | STL | C |
CAN
|
OHL |
| 156 | Bradley Eidsness |
BUF
|
6 | 6 | G |
CAN
|
AJHL | |
| 158 | Travis Erstad |
BUF
|
6 | 8 | SJS | F |
USA
|
USHL |
| 162 | Dan Dunn |
BUF
|
6 | 12 | PHL | G |
CAN
|
OPJRA |
| 166 | Josh Kidd |
BUF
|
6 | 16 | TBL | D |
CAN
|
OHL |
| 173 | Michael Ward |
BUF
|
6 | 23 | NSH | D |
CAN
|
QMJHL |
| 185 | Nick Eno |
BUF
|
7 | 5 | STL | G |
USA
|
EJHL |
| 186 | Brett Bellemore |
BUF
|
7 | 6 | D |
CAN
|
OHL | |
| 190 | Vili Sopanen |
BUF
|
7 | 10 | PIT | F |
FIN
|
FINLAND |
| 192 | Paul Byron |
BUF
|
7 | 12 | PHL | C |
CAN
|
QMJHL |